I don’t think I could live without Vegenaise mayonnaise. It’s so handy for making vegan potato salad and pretty nice to spread on a sandwich with a few slices of Tofurky. I feel the same way about Tofutti brand vegan sour cream; a dollop on top of a burrito or in a bowl of black bean soup makes all the difference in taste and texture.
But some vegans choose not to eat these foods. They object to the environmental and health costs of highly processed products made from soy and other plant proteins, and might even shun a nice friendly vegan cookie made with white flour.
It’s true that for responsible eating, nothing compares with whole plant foods. Legumes, nuts, seeds, whole grains, fruits and vegetables are the most healthful foods on earth and they take a smaller toll on the environment. They don’t require fancy packaging or huge amounts of energy for processing.
On the other hand, processed foods like meat and dairy analogues can make it much easier to take that leap from familiar omnivore meals to vegan cuisine. It’s already a challenge to convince people that vegan diets are delicious, fun and easy. Imagine how much harder it would be without products like Field Roast sausages, Coconut Bliss Ice Cream, Dandies marshmallows, and Nate’s Veggie Meatballs. For many new (and experienced) vegans, these foods make plant-based eating realistic and accessible. If they didn’t exist, the job of every vegan activist would be that much more difficult. And they will only exist—and continue to get better, more appealing, and less expensive—if vegans support the companies who make them.
The quest for a “perfect diet” is pretty much a lost cause anyway, since nutrition scientists have yet to define that ideal. For example, common wisdom tells us to eat lots of fruits and veggies, but the science hasn’t been at all consistent about the benefits of doing so. Maybe it’s better to eat more nuts or legumes. There continue to be questions about whether we should avoid fats or cook with a little bit more olive oil? Do we need more or less plant protein in our diets? Who knows?
When it comes to nutrition, there are far more questions than answers about the best way to eat. I guess we can say with considerable confidence that an apple is more healthful than a Twinkie, but beyond that, it doesn’t pay to be too perfectionist about diet.
Enjoying foods now and then that don’t fit into the “whole foods” ideal is very unlikely to do much harm to your health. It’s good activism, too, because it promotes the image of vegan diets as approachable and fun. And it supports the companies whose work and contributions are essential to building a more humane world.
You are right, I couldn't live without Vegenaise. I could definitely live without sugar and I do believe vegans need to eat healthier so we can be shining examples to the world.
Well said 🙂 It's funny, though, how I often don't even have the urge to eat the processed stuff–I buy Vegenaise and it ends up sitting in my fridge until it expires, but I think it's important that we show people the options we have. I like knowing I can rely on analogues sometimes. 🙂
I really like your article because it underscores that there is no one right way to promote veganism. I am also glad that you post so many wonderful recipes on your blog.
I doubt that I would ever have become vegan if not for getting the opportunity to eat meals prepared by a talented chef who was trained in vegan cooking. Fortunately, that is one of the perks I get to enjoy from living on The Farm and working at BookPubCo.
Very well said. I eat pretty high on the raw food side and once in a while a pint of dairy free frozen dessert or a meat analog burger is a fun treat and guilty pleasure all at the same time. I like to review them when I eat em because for some people meat and dairy analogs are a great help in becoming vegan and we need to bring mainstream attention to these products.
Really, it's not like it was even 10 years ago. The old products have improved and the new ones are very impressive. If you haven't tried the new meat analogs and cheeses you should just to see what they're like.
Great post ! This is the entire reason that the meat/dairy lobbyists (masquerading as environmentalists, naturalists, etc) bash soyfoods incessantly, because they know it's the perfect transition food for those considering eliminating their consumption of animal parts and fluids. The more misinformed fear and confusion they instill in the minds of the general public, the longer folks will just continue eating meat and dairy. It is critical that we, at every opportunity, expose the real origins and agendas behind the soy/vegan-bashing that continues to be granted wide access to so many forms of media.
Thanks so much, Ginny, for keeping the focus on creating as much change as possible, rather than only focusing on what our individual diets are.
Ginny….
I thank you for your spot on perspective. Transitional foods are an important part to realizing that much of what people think are the positive attributes of animal products are really more about texture and consistency pared with good seasoning. (See your post on sauces)
Processed foods also help us(and our kids) feel a bit less extreme, and feel like we are participating in "regular" society, plus we are hopefully voting vegan with our purchases.
Heya 🙂 I just found your blog and am very intrigued as I'm a vegan teenager. I noticed that you worked in Michigan and was wondering if you are still involved in the area as I live in the Detroit area. I am really interested in vegan living from a dietitian's point of view and hope that we can be in contact.
Thanks and have a lovely day!
I'm not a vegan but I love chickpeas and hummus. I found your poem on your blog, very clever. If you have a weird sense of humor you might like my blog Hummus Anonymous at kimsaddiction.blogspot.com.
Thanks so much for these excellent comments. I do think it's more important to make veganism easy than anything else. I love vegan convenience foods and I know they help lots of non-vegans eat fewer animal products.
Well, I think it's perfectly well established that whole foods are ALWAYS better than processed foods. I am sure we didn't evolve to process chemicals and preservatives more easily than plants. So the "there's no perfect diet" is not an excuse to eat processed foods. But I still won't apologize. If the whole world ate bland veggies all the time, I would too. But if everyone is going to be eating goodies all the time, I am not going to sit back, eat some salad and twigs, and promote negative vegan stereotypes. I liked this blog, though, because it's the first I've read with that viewpoint on that topic.
Good points in this blog. Ive been a vegan for almost 9 years and just put up a youtube video called 'raw vegan blood tests'.
Im inspired to be a healthy, fit vegan cos it gets the message across to the athletic world that I live in.
Everyone has their thing to do.
Increase the peace
Go Vegan! 🙂
http://www.30bananasaday.com
Good points in this blog. Ive been a vegan for almost 9 years and just put up a youtube video called 'raw vegan blood tests'.
Im inspired to be a healthy, fit vegan cos it gets the message across to the athletic world that I live in.
Everyone has their thing to do.
Increase the peace
Go Vegan! 🙂
http://www.30bananasaday.com
Agreed wholeheartedly! Veganaise rules and I've converted a HUGE amount of people in my life to Earth Balance. It really is amazing stuff.
One of my favorite mini-meals is a small corn tortilla rolled up with two slices of Tofurky, Veganaise and some salad greens. I make two and it's filling and not awful for you at all.
P.S. I've recently discovered this blog and love it. I write the "Meatless In Miami" column for the local alternative weekly and run meatlessmiami.com to make Miami more veg-friendly. Thanks for the great info!
Thanks so much, Lauren! I'm going to check out your column.
[…] use animal products, don’t eat animal products. However, there are some concerns over whether vegan ‘junk food’ and the ingredients often present in this food are a positive […]